Home

Charter

NFMA

Federal Register

USFS Letter

USDA Press Releases

Meet the Members

Meetings

Index of Documents

Working groups

The Public Forum

Related Links

 

Dr. K. Norman Johnson, Chair

Oregon State University

 

Dr. James Agee

University of Washington

 

Dr. Robert Beschta

Oregon State University

 

Dr. Virginia Dale

Oak Ridge National Lab.

Oak Ridge, TN

 

Dr. Linda Hardesty

Washington State Univ.

 

Dr. James Long

Utah State University

 

Dr. Larry Nielsen

Pennsylvania State Univ.

 

Dr. Barry Noon

Colorado State University

 

Dr. Roger Sedjo

Resources for the Future

Washington, D.C.

 

Dr. Margaret Shannon

Maxwell School of Citizenship & Public Affairs

Syracuse, NY

 

Dr. Ronald Trosper

Northern Arizona Univ.

 

Charles Wilkinson

University of Colorado

 

Dr. Julia Wondolleck

University of Michigan

MEMORANDUM

 

DATE: July 15, 1998

 

TO: The Committee of Scientists

 

FROM: K. Norman Johnson, Committee Chair

 

SUBJECT: Teleconference #4 Committee Meeting Notes

 

 

Enclosed are the notes from the fourth public teleconference call of the Committee of Scientists Federal Advisory Committee held July 10, 1998, from 11:00 am to 2:00 pm Eastern Daylight Time.

 

The purpose of the teleconference was to continue to discuss the committee's draft report to the Secretary of Agriculture and the Chief of the Forest Service. The public could participate on the telephone call at the Washington D.C. Office of the Forest Service and all regional offices of the Forest Service.

 

Enclosed you will find:

Attendance on July 10, 1998

Meeting minutes

 

 

Thank you for your participation in the meeting.

 

ATTENDANCE

July 10, 1998; TELECONFERENCE

 

COMMITTEE OF SCIENTISTS

ATTENDEES

Dr. Norm Johnson, Chair

Washington D.C. Office of Forest Service -

Dr. Robert Beschta

Cheryl Parkes-Ray, Forest Service

Dr. Linda Hardesty

Mary Munson, Defenders of Wildlife

Dr. Jim Long

Dr. Larry Nielsen

Region 3 -

Dr. Barry Noon

Doug Shaw, Forest Service

Dr. Margaret Shannon

Art Briggs, Forest Service

Dr. Ronald Trosper

Region 4 -

Charles Wilkinson

Kathy Hauser, Forest Service

 

Dave Iverson, Forest Service

Bob Cunningham, Designated Federal Official

Region 6 -

 

Shandra Smith, Forest Service

Committee Staff Support

Bill Connelly, Forest Service

Harriet Plumley, USFS

Les Mcconnell, Forest Service

 

Mauragrace Healey

 

Laura Cleland, Indep. Forest Products Assoc.

 

Region 8 -

 

Paul Arndt, Forest Service

 

Region 9 -

 

Jane Polasek, Forest Service

 

Region 10 -

 

Mary McClung, Forest Service

 
   

 

 

 

Minutes of July 10th Teleconference Call with Committee of Scientists

 

Format of Committee Report

 

Dr. Norm Johnson will bring a copy of the full report mockup, including graphics and illustrations, to Washington, D.C., on July 17 for Committee review. A suggestion to include two Table of Contents--one detailed and one for major headings only--at the beginning of the report was accepted.

 

The Committee discussed ways to highlight their recommendations, including numbering them, outlining them with boxes in the text, and showing them in the detailed Table of Contents.

 

Committee Meetings in Washington, D.C.

 

The latest schedule for the meetings is:

July 17, 11 am - 12 noon - meeting with Under Secretary Jim Lyons and Forest Service Chief Mike Dombeck

 

July 17, 1 - 1:30 pm - briefing with Secretary of Agriculture Dan Glickman

 

July 17, 2:30 - 4 pm - meeting with NFMA-regulation writing team and Advisory Team.

 

Dr. Johnson discussed his proposed outline for the briefings. For the Secretary’s briefing, Norm would provide a 15 minute summary of the Committee’s proposal with an emphasis on the principles of planning and allow 15 minutes for questions.

 

For the Under Secretary and Chief’s meeting, topics would be presented as follows:

    1. Introduction, with emphasis on principles - Norm Johnson
    2. Overview of guide to planning regulations - Charles Wilkinson
    3. Ecological sustainability, with emphasis on proposed regulation - Barry Noon
    4. Economic and social sustainability, democratic processes, and tribal rights - Julia Wondolleck, Margaret Shannon and Ron Trosper
    5. Proposed planning structure - Norm Johnson with Margaret Shannon
    6. Other influences on planning, including budgets and planning processes of other agencies - Roger Sedjo

 

Each topic should be presented in less than 5 to 7 minutes to allow about one-third of the time for questions. All Committee members should be available for specific questions.

 

 

Committee Report, Chapter 2

 

Dr. Shannon provided a summary of the changes and recommendations in Section 2B, "Social and Eonomic Sustainability". The Committee discussed the "Hispanic Communities." Suggestions were offered to better portray the way in which the Hispanic communities use forest resources for personal uses and household needs.

 

Dr. Shannon summarized the Democratic Processes subsection. A couple key points are that if a Forest planning team works with a group for a long time, the group should be appointed under FACA, and the role of the advisory boards is not just limited to planning, but to ongoing forest management as well. Dr. Johnson asked that the recommendations be pulled out and highlighted, and the language about the use of advisory boards strengthened to state that the Committee recommends use of advisory boards or some other mechanism to bring about long-term participation in the planning process.

 

Committee Report, Chapter 3

 

Dr. Johnson summarized changes to the proposed regulation on ecological sustainability, especially the "Species Diversity" and "Evaluation of Planning" subsections. Forest Service research scientists will need to provide assistance to planning teams in selecting "focal species" for viability analysis and identifying criteria from which to test how well species would do given certain management regimes.

 

The Committee discussed the limitations of restricting the viability regulations to native species only, given situations where nonnative species have become the only species capable of inhabiting certain areas, e.g., streams and lakes. The Committee agreed to discuss the problem in the preamble to the proposed regulations, but not to change the requirement to protect and restore the viability of native species.

 

Dr. Johnson summarized the section on the suitability of land for timber production. Land where timber can be harvested in support of other multiple use goals should be considered suitable land, but the allowable sale quantity should be calculated from only part of the suitable timber land, i.e., those lands where timber production is itself a goal. The report proposes a major shift in the way forests have evaluated timber lands and in the ways budgets and monitoring would be evaluated.

 

 

 

Comments from nonCommittee participants

 

Comments were heard from a few Forest Service planners about some of the goals and principles in Chapter 6, about concerns regarding the feasibility of completing the small landscape plans proposed in Chapter 4, and about the expected difficulties in getting budgets sufficient to conduct the proposed planning steps. There was a concern about the reference to the Klamath Tribes v. U.S. Forest Service lawsuit since the case became moot following the Sect. 318 recission act.

 

Some members of the public expressed concern about the current version of the proposed regulation on ecological sustainability, feeling that language should be stronger.